Grant Faulkner

  • Books
    • The Art of Brevity
    • All the Comfort Sin Can Provide
    • Fissures
    • Pep Talks for Writers
    • Nothing Short Of: Selected Tales from 100 Word Story
    • The Names of All Things
  • Stories
  • Essays
  • News/Interviews
  • Appearances
  • Podcast
  • Blog
  • Bio
  • Contact

Ian McEwan’s Supposed Plagiarism

December 4, 2006 by Grant Faulkner 2 Comments

Hurray for Charles Isherwood’s astute piece in the New York Times on all of the fuss about Ian McEwan “plagiarizing” bits of Atonement from a memoir he’d used in his research.

With each plagiarism scandal, I’ve wondered what constitutes plagiarism, especially with a novel. Should a novel include footnotes? My, that would ruin the reading experience–make it much harder to suspend disbelief, as all novels require. So many other arts are granted the liberties and joys of appropriation, of riffing on someone else’s melody at the very least, whether it’s painting, rap, or jazz. Even movies can mirror past scenes, and steal plots unabashedly. But not writing. There’s something too sacred about crafting a sentence, it seems.

Of course, McEwan wasn’t appropriating to make any sort of artistic commentary. More accurately, he failed to pick up a thesaurus to mix in a few synonyms for several descriptions from this World War II nurse’s memoir. The descriptions have nothing to do with the construction of his characters, dialogue, narrative design, or authorial voice–nothing to do with any of the crucial things that make a novel good. It’s interesting to me that so many are willing to parse through such small matters, as if McEwan deserves no credit for his achievement because of this small lapse, if it’s that.

It’s so difficult and rare for an author to write a great book. So many things go into it. Why even bring up a few borrowed words–yes, borrowed, not plagiarized? I’m sure McEwan’s transgressions could have gone much further before I’d ask for a trial. Even if he borrowed all of the words in the book from a 100 different sources, it would be quite an achievement to stitch it all together into such a fine book.

For more, read McEwan’s defense of himself.

Filed Under: Blog, Ian McEwan, writing process

Comments

  1. pepe says

    February 23, 2011 at 11:35 am

    i like your blog a lot. 🙂 keep posting!

    Reply
  2. Grant Faulkner says

    February 23, 2011 at 5:06 pm

    Thanks for the kind words, Pepe! Sometimes it feels like I’m just writing for myself, so I always appreciate a good reader.

    Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Social Media

Facebook Twitter Instagram LinkedIn

Subscribe to my newsletter!

Bio

Executive Director of National Novel Writing Month, co-founder of 100 Word Story, writer, tap dancer, alchemist, contortionist, numbskull, preacher. Read More…

The Art of Brevity

Cover of Art of Brevity

Buy from Bookshop.org

All the Comfort Sin Can Provide

Book Cover - All the Comfort Sin Can Provide

Buy from Bookshop.org!

Pep Talks for Writers: 52 Insights and Actions to Boost Your Creative Mojo

Bookshop.org
Amazon
Barnes & Noble
IndieBound

Fissures

Grant Faulkner Fissures

Bookshop.org
Amazon

Nothing Short of 100

Grant Faulkner Fissures

Buy now!

The Names of All Things

Grant Faulkner Fissures

Buy now!

Recent Posts

  • Author’s Note: The Art of Brevity
  • A Creative Manifesto
  • The Ides of March: The Most Dangerous Time for New Year’s Resolutions
  • Pep Talks for Writers: 52 Insights and Actions to Boost Your Creative Mojo
  • On Failing Better, Failing Bigger, Failing Magnificently

Tags

Community cover design Creative Process Experimental Fiction Favorite Authors Flash Fiction Inspiration Literary Critique Literary Magazines NaNoWriMo Philosophy Photography Poetry Reading Revision Self-publishing Short Story Writing Detail Writing Tips Writing Voice

Copyright © 2023 · Metro Pro Theme on Genesis Framework · WordPress · Log in