Grant Faulkner

  • Books
    • The Art of Brevity
    • All the Comfort Sin Can Provide
    • Fissures
    • Pep Talks for Writers
    • Nothing Short Of: Selected Tales from 100 Word Story
    • The Names of All Things
  • Stories
  • Essays
  • News/Interviews
  • Appearances
  • Podcast
  • Blog
  • Bio
  • Contact

Gilead…Pulitzer?

September 3, 2007 by Grant Faulkner Leave a Comment

I should have trusted my instincts. When I first read the excerpt from Gilead in The New Yorker, I was bored out of my skull. Still, Marilynne Robinson was one of my favorites contemporary authors—I’ve probably bought more copies of Housekeeping for friends than any other book.

And then there were all of the rave reviews for Gilead. And then, of course, the Pulitzer. It’s pretty damn hard to argue with a Pulitzer, right?

So I bought the book. I was as bored after a few pages as I’d been when reading the excerpt in The New Yorker. I kept trudging on, however—how could this novel not deliver something astonishing?—and even up to the last few pages, I kept expecting something great, a final twist or turn of phrase or bit of wisdom that would make the whole drudgerous reading exercise redeeming. But no.

This is the sort of novel that makes one question literary prizes. Did Robinson essentially get this Pulitzer for Housekeeping (which is fine if that’s the case)? It reminds me of when Paul Newman received an Oscar for his performance in The Color of Money, a crappy film, especially when compared to his work in its predecessor, The Hustler, not to mention his other great films. The lesson: Never trust a book that’s received an award (especially if a great book preceded it).

I also question the reviewers and Robinson’s editors. James Wood said in his New York Times review, “Gilead is a beautiful work — demanding, grave and lucid — and is, if anything, more out of time than Robinson’s book of essays, suffused as it is with a Protestant bareness.”

“Protestant bareness” is a nice way of saying the prose was flat, only faintly expressive at best. I didn’t glean any grave or demanding religious truths from the work. Worse, especially in literary terms, the novel’s characters were without dimension for the most part, in particular the narrator’s son, who the novel is supposedly written for (as one long, meandering letter). He’s a nice boy who likes to play—that’s about all of the characterization there is. I know plenty of five-year-old boys who beg for sharper, more nuanced portraits than Robinson gives this stereotypical little tyke.

The narrator’s wife is equally lacking in dimension—a shame since as a younger, less educated wife, she begs for so much more drama. And this is what the book is fundamentally lacking, drama.

I’m all for a quiet, meditative narrative, a religious novel, but despite some tender, evocative moments, Robinson doesn’t truly deliver this note. It reads as what it is in fiction: an old man’s letter, meant to be read by no one other than his son.

Filed Under: Blog, Uncategorized

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Social Media

Facebook Twitter Instagram LinkedIn

Subscribe to my newsletter!

Bio

Executive Director of National Novel Writing Month, co-founder of 100 Word Story, writer, tap dancer, alchemist, contortionist, numbskull, preacher. Read More…

The Art of Brevity

Cover of Art of Brevity

Buy from Bookshop.org

All the Comfort Sin Can Provide

Book Cover - All the Comfort Sin Can Provide

Buy from Bookshop.org!

Pep Talks for Writers: 52 Insights and Actions to Boost Your Creative Mojo

Bookshop.org
Amazon
Barnes & Noble
IndieBound

Fissures

Grant Faulkner Fissures

Bookshop.org
Amazon

Nothing Short of 100

Grant Faulkner Fissures

Buy now!

The Names of All Things

Grant Faulkner Fissures

Buy now!

Recent Posts

  • Author’s Note: The Art of Brevity
  • A Creative Manifesto
  • The Ides of March: The Most Dangerous Time for New Year’s Resolutions
  • Pep Talks for Writers: 52 Insights and Actions to Boost Your Creative Mojo
  • On Failing Better, Failing Bigger, Failing Magnificently

Tags

Community cover design Creative Process Experimental Fiction Favorite Authors Flash Fiction Inspiration Literary Critique Literary Magazines NaNoWriMo Philosophy Photography Poetry Reading Revision Self-publishing Short Story Writing Detail Writing Tips Writing Voice

Copyright © 2023 · Metro Pro Theme on Genesis Framework · WordPress · Log in